Close this search box.

Is Your SEO Working? How to Check SEO Effectiveness (Free Quiz)


Wondering how to check SEO effectiveness?

Take our free quiz to find out (no email required).

SEO, or Search Engine Optimization, is the key to driving qualified leads to your business. However, SEO is not an overnight success story; it requires time, effort, and patience to see results. You may often find yourself wondering if your SEO efforts are paying off. To help you navigate this journey, I’ve created a comprehensive quiz that acts as a guideline to evaluate the effectiveness of your SEO strategy.

Factors to consider when assessing your SEO effectiveness

1. How often do you perform keyword research?

Keyword research is the foundation of any successful SEO strategy. Regularly conducting keyword research helps ensure that you’re targeting relevant and high-traffic search terms. I recommend performing comprehensive keyword research at least once a quarter. Tools like Ahrefs, SEMrush, Google’s Keyword Planner, Ubersuggest, and Answer The Public are great options to gain valuable insights into keyword performance and trends.

2. What tools do you use to track your website’s SEO performance?

Monitoring your SEO efforts is crucial. Tools like Google Analytics, Google Search Console, and specialized SEO tools like Ahrefs and SEMrush are indispensable. These tools help you track metrics such as organic traffic, bounce rate, average session duration, and keyword rankings. Consistent monitoring allows you to identify what’s working and what needs improvement. Be sure to read the section below on important SEO metrics to measure

3. How do you measure the success of your SEO efforts?

Success in SEO can be measured through various key performance indicators (KPIs). Common KPIs include organic traffic growth, improvement in keyword rankings, increased click-through rates (CTR), and higher conversion rates. Define clear goals for each KPI and measure them against your baseline performance to measure success. Be sure to read the section below on important SEO metrics to measure

4. How often do you publish new content on your website?

Regular content publication is essential for maintaining and improving SEO performance. I recommend publishing new, high-quality content at least once a week. Fresh content keeps your audience engaged and signals to search engines that your site is active and relevant. Incorporate both primary and secondary keywords naturally into your content to maximize its SEO potential.

5. Do you optimize your content with both primary and secondary keywords?

Effective SEO content optimization goes beyond just targeting primary keywords. Include secondary keywords and related terms to capture a broader audience and enhance content relevance. Use tools like Yoast SEO (watch my Yoast SEO tutorial) and Detailed SEO (watch my Detailed SEO tutorial) to ensure your content is optimized for your target keywords without overstuffing.

6. How do you handle SEO for local searches?

Local SEO is crucial for businesses that serve specific geographic areas. Optimize your Google My Business profile, include local keywords in your content, and ensure your name, address, and phone number (NAP) are consistent across all online directories. Encourage satisfied customers to leave positive reviews, as they significantly impact local search rankings. Review my Google Business Profile for inspiration (and while you’re at it – feel free to leave a positive review about this blog post ;))

7. Do you analyze and use your competitors’ SEO strategies to inform your own?

Competitor analysis can provide valuable insights into what works in your industry. Use tools like Ahrefs or SEMrush to analyze your competitors’ backlinks, content strategies, and keyword rankings. This information can help you identify gaps in your own strategy and uncover new opportunities for improvement.

8. How do you approach link building for your website?

Link building remains a critical component of SEO. Focus on acquiring high-quality backlinks from reputable sites. Strategies include guest blogging, creating shareable content, and building relationships with industry influencers. Avoid black-hat tactics like buying links, as they can lead to severe penalties from search engines. Learn more about backlinks here.

9. Have you ever conducted an SEO audit of your website?

Regular SEO audits are essential to maintain and improve your site’s performance. An audit can identify technical issues, on-page SEO problems, and opportunities for content improvement. Conduct an SEO audit at least twice a year using tools like Screaming Frog, Ahrefs, or SEMrush. I also offer a comprehensive SEO Audit + Strategy service.

10. How do you respond to changes in SEO performance based on your analytics?

SEO requires constant vigilance and adaptability. Regularly review your analytics to identify trends and changes in performance. If you notice a drop in traffic or rankings, investigate the cause and adjust your strategy accordingly. Stay informed about algorithm updates and industry trends to ensure your SEO tactics remain effective.

SEO Metrics to Measure

1. Organic Traffic

The most obvious sign of successful SEO is an increase in organic traffic. Organic traffic refers to visitors who find your site through search engines like Google, without any paid advertising. Use Google Analytics to monitor your organic traffic over time. Look for trends and spikes that correlate with your SEO activities, such as content updates, backlink acquisitions, or technical optimizations.

2. Keyword Rankings

Tracking your keyword rankings is crucial for understanding how well your site is performing in search engine results. Tools like Ahrefs, SEMrush, and Moz can help you monitor your keyword positions. Focus on keywords that are relevant to your business and have a good search volume. If you see improvements in rankings for your target keywords, it’s a strong indicator that your SEO strategies are effective.

3. Conversion Rate

Driving traffic is great, but converting that traffic into leads or sales is the ultimate goal. Analyze your conversion rate by tracking how many visitors complete desired actions on your website, such as filling out a form, making a purchase, or signing up for a newsletter. A high conversion rate signifies that not only are you attracting visitors, but you’re also providing them with valuable and relevant content.

4. Bounce Rate and Dwell Time

Bounce rate measures the percentage of visitors who leave your site after viewing only one page, while dwell time refers to the amount of time visitors spend on your site. A high bounce rate and low dwell time may indicate that your content isn’t engaging or relevant. Improving these metrics often involves optimizing your content to better match user intent and making your site more navigable and visually appealing. Learn more about bounce rate and dwell time.

5. Backlink Profile

Backlinks are a critical factor in SEO success. They signal to search engines that your site is authoritative and trustworthy. Use free tools like the Ahrefs Backlink Checker or Majestic Backlink Checker to analyze your backlink profile. Look for an increase in the number of high-quality backlinks from reputable sites.

6. Page Load Speed

Page load speed is a significant ranking factor for search engines and a crucial element of user experience. Slow-loading pages can frustrate users and lead to higher bounce rates. Use Google PageSpeed Insights or GTmetrix to evaluate your site’s load times and identify areas for improvement. Faster load times typically lead to better SEO performance and user satisfaction.

7. Click-Through Rate (CTR)

Click-Through Rate (CTR) is an essential metric that shows how often people click on your site’s link when it appears in search results. A high CTR indicates that your title tags and meta descriptions are compelling and relevant to users’ search queries. You can monitor CTR using Google Search Console. Improving your CTR can lead to more organic traffic and better overall SEO performance.

When Should You Consider Updating Your SEO Plan?

To improve your website’s SEO performance, it’s crucial to know when to update your SEO plan. Here are some key moments to consider:

  1. After an Algorithm Update: Search engines frequently update their algorithms, which can impact your rankings. Stay informed about these updates and adjust your strategy accordingly.

  2. When You Launch New Products or Services: Introducing new offerings can change your target keywords and audience. Update your SEO plan to reflect these changes.

  3. If You Notice a Decline in Performance: A drop in traffic or rankings is a clear sign that your SEO strategy needs a review. Conduct an SEO audit to identify and fix issues.

  4. Regularly, at Least Quarterly: SEO is an ongoing process. Regular reviews and updates to your SEO plan ensure that you stay on top of trends and maintain optimal performance.

  5. When Expanding to New Markets: Entering new geographic or demographic markets requires local SEO adjustments to target new audiences effectively.

  6. When It’s Been a Long Time Without Noticeable Improvements: If it’s been a while and you haven’t seen significant improvements in your SEO metrics, it might be time to reevaluate your strategy. Sometimes, the current approach just isn’t working, and a fresh perspective or new tactics are needed.


Updating your SEO plan at these critical times helps maintain and enhance your website’s visibility, ensuring that your SEO efforts continue to drive qualified leads to your business.


Evaluating your SEO effectiveness is an ongoing process that requires attention to detail and a proactive approach. Remember, the ultimate goal of SEO is to drive qualified leads to your business. Our quiz is designed to provide a starting point for identifying areas of improvement and ensuring your SEO strategy remains robust and effective. Keep in mind that SEO results take time, so patience and consistent effort are key. Stay diligent, adapt to changes, and watch your business grow through effective SEO practices.

And, if you’re feeling like your SEO could use some work, be sure to check out our On-Page SEO Checklist below!

Hey there!

Thank you for stopping by! My name is Samantha and I’ve been developing websites and doing SEO since 2020. At Samantha Digital, we aim to offer value-packed resources for small businesses relating to web design, SEO, and digital marketing. If you have any questions, please send me a message.

- Sam

Latest Posts:

Latest Posts

Related Posts

Meet the Author

Picture of Samantha


Samantha is the founder of Samantha Digital, a leading web design and SEO company specializing in empowering small businesses. With a passion for digital marketing, Samantha has helped numerous clients enhance their online presence and achieve their business goals. With her expertise in web design and search engine optimization, she is dedicated to delivering tailored solutions that drive visibility, engagement, and growth for her clients. Samantha's commitment to excellence and her creative approach to digital strategies make her a trusted partner for businesses seeking to thrive in the digital landscape.

What do you think? Leave a comment below!

We want to hear from you!